Free classified ads | Online Auctions | Our Weeklies | Long distance call | Weblocal
novanewsnow.com
NNN Banner
Send this text to a friend Print this article Comment on this article

Brochure cover drawing sparks Sam Slick celebration controversy

Angry residents plan protest march for Saturday

by Christy Marsters/The Hants Journal
View all articles from Christy Marsters/The Hants Journal
Article online since July 29th 2008, 13:05
Read all 32 comments about this article / Comment on this article
Brochure cover drawing sparks Sam Slick celebration controversy
Jeffrey Upshaw and Craig Allison were less than impressed by an image published on the cover of the 2008 Sam Slick Days festival programs, which were distributed throughout Hants County. The picture left many questioning Sam Slick’s character. Christy Marsters
Brochure cover drawing sparks Sam Slick celebration controversy
Angry residents plan protest march for Saturday
By Christy Marsters

The Hants Journal/NovaNewsNow.com

Craig Allison pulled the 2008 Sam Slick Days festival program from his flyer package July 28 as he hoped to see the all activities planned for the big weekend in Windsor.

But, he never opened the booklet, and was left staring in outrage at an image on the cover.

It was a sketch taken from the archives of images by C.W. Jefferys, which was based on the Clockmaker stories of Sam Slick originally created by Windsor native Thomas Chandler Haliburton.

The sketch shows a man of obvious African background knelt down with his arms clutched around Sam Slick. Disheveled and his mouth hanging open, the man looks up at Slick the clockmaker -- who is nattily dressed in coat and top hat and appears to be drawing away from him.

Allison, a resident of Windsor Plains, said the sketch represents more than a picture to the African-Nova Scotian community. “I feel humiliated by it… It makes all the old stereotypes come back.”

Allison held a quiet protest and petition signing Saturday, Aug. 2,for the community to stop celebrating the racist character that, he feels, is Sam Slick. Allison had said earlier, “...I would love to see the support of the whole community.”

Sam Slick Society president Bruce Shaw said the sketch was an oversight, which was unfortunate for everyone, but it was also taken out of context, the wrong way.

The picture actually shows the man crying out in pleasure to see Slick, Shaw said. “He’s throwing himself at Sam...”

However, people have every right to be upset by the image because people do interpret things differently, Shaw said. “I was as surprised and disappointed to see that this picture was published as anyone else… And I apologize to the people who took offense to it.”

Hopefully, everyone can realize this was a mistake and move forward, Shaw said.

About 8,000 copies of the brochure were distributed.

Mayor Anna Allen says she can’t comment on the mistake because it's the business of the Sam Slick Society and not the town. “But I wish the Sam Slick Society well,” she said.

“I hope the festival is a great success this year; as it has been in the past,” Allen added.

Vince Upshaw, an employment navigator with the West Hants African Resource Centre, said he has spoken with Shaw from the Sam Slick Society and realizes the publication of this image was a mistake. “However, I would like to see lessons learned from this.”

The process of publication should be slowed down and people should take the time to consider there were a lot of feelings hurt from this image, Upshaw said. “To the black community, this was a slap in the face… and an embarrassment to our population.

“It hurts self esteem,” Upshaw said. “When I saw the image, it made me want to cry.”

Also, some research should be done on Haliburton to find out exactly the type of person he was, Upshaw added. “I would like to know: is he an honorable man or is he not?”

These articles could also interest you

Linked photos

Your comments

Full name:
(required)


Email address:


Your comments :
(required)


Please retype the word displayed below Can't read the word?

Please retype the word displayed below:


Tired

Comment online since August 5th 2008
I hope the weekend was a success for the whole community. I do believe that racism exists, but only exists do to ignorance. If we learn more about one another, whether we are white, black, brown, yellow or any shade of the rainbow we the human race comes in. I believe that the Sam Slick weekend should be a learning experience as well as a party.

If we want to make a change we need to have more interaction and education about one another. Maybe next year the festival can have community booth displaying the different histories of each ethnic society. History in regards to Windsor/Hants County.

If all we do now is point fingers and accuse people of racists symbols and acts than the community suffers. Me being of Irish and Scottish heritage do not know all about what it was and is like to be of another ethnic background, even though I have a lot of ethnic friends. I just want more dialogue on these issue. Take care.

mama g

Comment online since August 5th 2008
I was pretty upset over the whole cariacture printed on the Sam Slick program this year. As a parent of bi-racial children i have to be on the look out for any type of negative depicitions of their heritage and this was very negative! I feel there should be more visable minorities involved with the society, and there should definately not be any members on there who are racist of whom i have been told of one in particular, so maybe there should be some type of "screening" involved prior to accepting people onto this board. It is also particular to me that every year the program comes out all that you see are caucasion people no minorities, this community has many visable minorities and i feel that it is rude and disrespectful to not show them in the program , they come out and support this festival every year too!!!!I hope that the society has learned a lesson from this , i mean we are all human and we make mistakes to learn from them!!!!

Believe it or not.

Comment online since August 4th 2008
Alright I must point out nice Tommy shirt Craig!
I do believe that this picture of Sam Slick wasn't printed out by a mistake. Nobody makes stupid mistakes like that and get away with it. The persons who did the editing of this front cover had too know that someone/ others would jump on it like fire.
No matter what's said and done racist will always be apart of everybodys life. These days they call it bullying/ picking on people.
That picture could mean anything but everyone knows what it truly means and it's a hurtful picture too everyone.
Do you know how it makes a white person feel too see that picture? Because I know how it feels and deep down I know how it makes the black people feel :( It's really sad that our history was so bad but that's why we have this future too make our people realize we all love each other for who we are and what we all become.

Lets enjoy what we have now and ... fight the past

saddened

Comment online since August 3rd 2008
I too am a former resident of windsor,i grew up with racism,not as bad as my parents did,but after leaving windsor and living away for a number of years,I have seen racism everywhere.Its a sad thing but we as ppl have to change,we have to live together work together raise our children together,but our children will change racism,if in fact we teach them and show them the way.as for the pcture on the brochure,all i have to say it had to go through a lot of hands before it was printed,didn't one of those people have the common sense to THINK before it got this far....

Think about it

Comment online since August 2nd 2008
Ok I have read enough!! I agree this should not be done in front of small kids between a parade! My kids do not know what racism is and I don't want them to know I want them to grow up and believe everyone is the same inside and color does not make a difference on the outside. Do I agree with the protest? ABSOLUTELY the picture was WRONG I can't believe it went to print but... why not protest outside the place that acutually published the picture? It really has nothing to do with the actual events. Sam Slick Days has always been about Fun, and togetherness I really don't think about the history behind it, but if the history is what ppl are saying it is then change the name next year. What is going to happen if one racial slur comes from one idiot in the crowd the ppl who are protesting are going to argue back, and you are going to have a brawl and a whole bunch of small kids in the middle. THEN WHAT!!Well there goes the fun, and because of this I am staying home this year. So make your point, state your drama cause Windsor is not happy unless there is DRAMA have your fun and enjoy your protest and thanks for ruining it for the kids that enjoy the tossing of the candy and the firemen dog. Because thats what you are doing. But have fun stating YOUR point cause that is all that matters OR IS IT???

Lia Glover

Comment online since August 1st 2008
Mr. Allison, no need to burn the shirt. You have done nothing wrong. The whole Tommy thing was just another rumour as I mentioned in my note below. It was a relief - and a class act - to see that Ms. Chase did the research and apologized. It's too bad the the person who first mentioned it - note they did not identify themselves - did not apologize. To make things even more confusing, that same person identifies the man wearing the shirt as, Craig Upshaw! Do your research sir or madam. And sign your name like the rest of us.

Anyway, Mr. Allison....wear the shirt with a clear conscience.

Shame On Us

Comment online since August 1st 2008
Shame on us for assuming!! As a community who has celebrated Sam Slick for many many years, who are we to point a finger at 1 or 2 people for an error in judgement. We are fortunate enough to have an African Resource Centre and we need to trust that the centre and its employees are acting in the best interest of the community. If Vince is in support then it must be in the best interest of the community as well. The history has always been there...we need to take responsibility for not researching ourselves!!

Michelle V

Comment online since August 1st 2008
I am confused as to why everyone seems to be attacking Vince Upshaw. I do not dispute that the picture is offensive to African Canadians however it needs to be reiterated that he did not choose the picture. Vince reacted to the photo as many African Canadians did...offended. It is sad and disheartening to think that he has very little support from "family" and "friends" to carry out the event. As an employee with the African Resource Centre, Vince would have obligations to the centre and the community to continue with the events. It is even more important for the comminity to rally together and celebrate instead of waiving the race card around. The community needs to come together in celebration and support. We need to end racism by educating others and displaying tolerance for one another.

Eveyone should feel ashamed

Comment online since August 1st 2008
I commend Vince Upshaw for all the hard work and time he has put into his community ..it is very upsetting to see how quick people are to jump on him for his mature additude in dealing with this. How many years have we all enjoyed the festivites of Sam Slick without researching what we were celebrating ..Shame on us all.

Di (Ducky) Sherman

Comment online since August 1st 2008
I must say the community has taken it for a long time. And turned the cheek many times. After all these years, it just amazes me that people can't be more thoughtful for and of one another.

Growing up in the TMP, a community that accepted you for you, which was called, "Wrong Side of the Tracks," Most of us stood side by side and took the brunt of it all from Elementary school to Windsor Regional High School and helped one another.

The planning committee should have been more careful with the selection of their cartoon for this year.

The children are the ones that will suffer. As adults, history repeats itself. Bascially I fear that what we had heard growing up will again reappear and come to haunt the children in the Community and neighboring. All the hard work to stop the racism us has reappeared thanks to one twisted Judge's cartoon and a committee.

Upset

Comment online since August 1st 2008
Yes, we the black community are upset. You say not in front of the kids. Well it has affected our children as well. They are saying "this is wrong and we should do something about". but i guess we should set back and take it. Show our children that we will stand by and let these things happen. What kind of example should we set for our children. Show them that yes they put out a picture that hurt us but we need to let it go not say a word,let it hurt but lets not show it, forget about it and let them do what they want. Thats how it has been for years and we need to let it go. Is this the example that you teach your children. I would hope not so why are people asking us to not say a word.

As for having a African resource center I think that is great. Especially when it doors are open to all races. They help everyone. I don't hear people putting down other organization that are for other groups of people.

Carolyn Chase

Comment online since August 1st 2008
My apologies to Craig Allison. I just spent some time searching article after article about this Tommy thing and it NEVER HAPPENED! Simply a rumor. Oprah has emphatically stated that she never had him on her show and had never even met the man until last year when she finally had him on her show to put an end to this rumor. I always thought it was odd for someone to say something like that to Oprah. See how rumors can escalate? You don't need to get rid of your clothes, Craig. Sorry about that and thank you SO MUCH for standing up for this issue with the Sam Slick brochure. Thank God for people like you and your friend.

craig allison

Comment online since August 1st 2008
I am sorry that people who seen my tommy shirt have made some negative remarks. I had no idea that it was offensive i will watch the oprah show in question. I promise that tommy hilfiger will not be part of my vast wardrobe again and if anyone would like to watch i will burn the lot.

Lia Glover

Comment online since August 1st 2008
The Tommy Hilfiger remark. That remark was never made on her show. She had him on post-remark to clarify if he had ever made that comment ever, let alone on her show.

He denied making that statement and whether he said it outside of her show - maybe he did - has anyone ever heard it? Given all the media out there, I am sure it would be on youtube. In any event, he definitely never said it on her show and he was just there to clarify that.

Just another example of heresay and inaccurate information being thrown around, thus causing more division.











here is no record o

Carolyn Chase

Comment online since August 1st 2008
With regard to the Comment entitled "Are You Kidding Me?", you ask who the real racist is - uh, that would be you. You obviously are white and have never felt the sting of being bullied or discriminated against due to the color of your skin and until then, I guess you will never understand and always be ignorant and inconsiderate. I would love to see you sent back in time and turned into a slave for awhile.

By the way, I, too, was shocked that the gentleman in the photo was wearing a Tommy shirt too. I can only imagine he never saw that Oprah show.

Question

Comment online since August 1st 2008
And why would Craig Upshaw be wearing a Tommy Hilfiger
shirt.Many of us must recall the quest visit this designer made on Oprah...when he stated something to the effect that had he known so many black people were going to wear his close he would never have designed them.This was a huge controversial issue in which many people,including white people refused to purchase anymore of his designs.So tell me who is contradicting himself with this whole issue.

Good Lord

Comment online since August 1st 2008
How many events does this community have that interests all members of this community?The answer...not many.Does anyone make a big deal of the events and opportunities set out for the black community only?No,everybody just lets it go.It's about time that equal means equal.Nobody owes anybody anything in this day and age.It was many years ago and those of a mixed race must realize it was their ancestors too.There were also many whites that went against what they were supposed to and hid and protected slaves.Recall the little white house in TMP belonging to Minnie DeWolf..so much history there.So it was not all white people even back then.Now I will agree there is still prejudice that exists but it is of all colors.Just listen to hip hop..now how do we explain to young children that they cannot use certain words because it is offensive in yet the person it would offend is singing it.How is this equal?Things will never be equal until special opportunities and circumstances are not limited to individual groups.I myself feel for the young white male trying to enter the work force or further his career because where are their any breaks for him but I don't see any protests started over this.Why..to keep peace and not start something that will destroy all the steps taken to make our world a better place.

Cindy Rafuse

Comment online since August 1st 2008
I would like to respond to those who believe that Vince Upshaw was remiss when he stated he "realized the publication of this image was a mistake."

There appear to be those (who have responded electronically to this article) with the expressed intent of villifying Vince Upshaw for this comment, and his belief that a mistake was made; many were hurt (including Mr. Upshaw); and that lessons should be learned.


I applaud Mr. Upshaw for having the courage and tenacity to comment on this situation; as well his ability to recognize that blame and racial division are never answers, they are only catalysts which will continue to fuel the flames of racial tension.

I can only wish that others will as Mr.Vince Upshaw stated, "learn lessons from this". The question is.....what lesson will you choose to learn?

Martock Girl

Comment online since August 1st 2008
Right on! It's about time. I have always protested Sam Slick celebrations just for this reason. Some should reason their history to better understand what Judge Haliburton famous books are about. Yes, Sam Slick is fictional but it is what is written in the books by the author. In the time period it was the norm but times have changed. That type of thinking is no more and not acceptable. Way to go Vince and Craig!!

in front of the children

Comment online since July 31st 2008
will there be a protest in front of all those children on saturday? If so is that the message u want to send to children?

Tired of ignorance.

Comment online since July 31st 2008
I am tired of ignorance. Tired of people not doing their job. The Sam Slick Society is at fault of being racially ignorant, maybe having someone of colour in the Society would help when making decisions about relaying information of and on the character Sam Slick.

I am a former resident of Hants County and know the writings of Thomas Chandler Haliburton. He and his subject do not seem to be a overtly racist especially considering the time he was alive. Ignorance is colour blind, so I suggest to Mr. Upshaw if he wants research done on Haliburton he should do it himself and that way he can draw his own conclusions. I hope you have all great weekend, I wish I could be there.

Are you kidding me?

Comment online since July 31st 2008
So a story book character is capable of being racist? Personally I'd like to know who the real "racist" is... West Hants African Resource Centre? if you want to be treated equal, why must you continue to have groups that exclude all other races??? What Hypocrites! I can't stand how every little thing gets your knickers in a knot! get over it!

Angie Armstrong

Comment online since July 31st 2008
Ok first of all I am a white female who was told about the drawing before seeing it and after seeing it my reaction was "why in the world would that drawing have been published"?I mean it had to go through a lot of hands and eyes before circulation.I was offended and ashamed and surely it had to have done the same for at least one of the individuals who viewed it before publication.That being said, I understand the hurt feelings for all of the community because as mentioned in another comment this event is to gather with old friends and family..it is a social event that brings back people from afar and near who only reunite this one time every year.As far as the committee and their choice,I will not defend but as a community lets not turn this into a racial event.It has effected more than just the black community..it brings back memories to all,also those who are not proud of their ancestors actions.This is a new generation.Lets not make this festival a racial experience for our children whom are raised to treat all equally.The society did all they can do at this point with regards to the drawing and as far as I am concerned Vince handled the situation in a mature manner.He brought it to the attention of the committee explaining the message it conveyed listened to the apology and is now trying to keep it peaceful.I am sure he is still offended and hurt over the ordeal but really why turn it into an outright war.Shouldn't we stick together as a community as we are when saying the choice was bad. Lets not just seperate the white from the black which is just going to take us back to years ago and I don't think any of us want to take those steps backwards.I certainly don't want my children to have to grow up that way in this generation.This is a good community, a good event,lets not take that away.The research should be done and if Sam Slick is proven to support Racism then by all means do something about the title of this celebration but until then lets all reunite again this year as a whole community.Stop with the protest it will only make things a whole lot worse.

Hard to let go

Comment online since July 31st 2008
I don't understand the fuss either. I know the artist who drew the picture and she is the farthest thing from racist. If she weren't, we would likely not be friends because I, too, am of a coloured background.
Had it been a poor, homeless white man, would you have cried status discrimination? Fact: homeless people get treated brutally and experienced discrimination as well. What if it had been an Asian? Would you have caused a public outcry about it? Don't forget to count how many Asians died building the railroad for a mere pittance and who were constantly discriminated against and treated no better than slaves; in a country that had no slavery and was integral to the freedom of slaves during that period in history. Would you, as an African-Canadian stand up and protest the racial depiction of either one of these groups of people? What if it was a gay man kneeling ther, or a lesbian, for that matter? Do yougive a damn about discrimination if it doesn't involve your skin colour? Apathy towards the plight of other disparaged groups is a form of racism itself; think about it. This separatist attitude practiced by the various groups in this world is the exact reason we will never evolve as a species.
Black and Beautiful: Yes, there will always be prejudice, not just against colour, but also against sexuality, age (believe it), religion, status... it's going to be there. But you can choose to let it affect you, or you can choose not to. And rather than get steamed up on the spot, why not find out about the artist who drew the image? There was no racial intent behind the image she drew; she was drawing a scene as she read in a book that appeared to be a joyous moment. There can only be a racism if there was racial intent.
Unless we can forgive the past and forget our differences, we will never move forward.

Ross Mckeil

Comment online since July 31st 2008
I feel that everyone is completely over reacting. As it has been pointed out, the black man in the photo is happy to see Slick, Sam Slick has just freed him from slavery. It a celebration, why are the people in the black community upset? They should be happy that the publication is promoting such a positive image of a black man showing his appreciation for being freed from slavery. If the this paper printed a picture of a white man on his knees hugging the leg of a fireman, because he is so thankful he was just pulled him from a burning house. Would there be a public out cry. I doubt it. I don't understand the black community, they seem to grab onto every little thing and make issue with it, they seem to bring racism to the forefront whether it is warranted or not. The people from the Sam Slick society should be praised for the wonderful job they have done and are doing, its countless hours for little reward. Relax people, don't be so uptight. ENJOY THE FESTIVAL.

Frustrated

Comment online since July 30th 2008
Why does this continue to happen? By having these "seriously outdated opinions"(Black and Beautiful) we continue to add fuel to the fire. I agree that the picture for the print add should not have even made it to the presses, but at a time when we are hearing of the disgrace in Digby a few short weeks ago in the news, Why would people young or old, ugly or beautiful, black or white... want to spread the disease of Racism by making such comments as (and I quote) "Racism will never stop so face that fact"? Have the people who are protesting even read the book? Is Sam Slick even a real person or is he a FICTIONAL CHARACTER? What are we protesting? the celebration in Windsor? The picture in the flyer? Or the work of Haliburton?

Just an opinion

Comment online since July 30th 2008
Maybe someone should actually read the novel and find out who Sam Slick "is" before they start acting all crazy. Yes, the picture could have been and was taken negatively, as was it offensive to many persons of African decent within the community and that I am not supporting- it should never have been printed. That being said, you cannot jump into something (protest) with ignorance. Get the necessary information and then decide what you want to do. If proper research is done that concludes Sam Slick a racist, I support the end of the celebrations however, if it is true and he was in fact freeing a slave and acting as a hero, why not celebrate him?

no side here

Comment online since July 30th 2008
It is a sad day when a young black woman puts into print that black will never be equal to white. How are we ever going to change the views of the white community when we do not belive it in the black community. You say you are going to protest the festival but for what reason? You should be fighting for something you believe in not for just the sake of fighting.
I do not understand your stand where Vince Upshaw is concered? I watched the interview and clearly he had the same views as many and that was that the pictures were hutful and wrong. How is it that he is "protecting" anyone?
Racism will stop if we teach it to, so face that fact.

Sandy Hill

Comment online since July 30th 2008
I think the root of the problem derives from the fact that the Sam Slick Heritage Society has never used the Sam Slick festival to promote the literary works of Thomas Haliburton, therefore the general public is somewhat uninformed about who this fictional character of who Sam Slick is, and what the author, Mr. Haliburton was writing about at that time.
For all of the years I have attended the Sam Slick festival, it was always about friends and family getting together, seeing fireworks and watching the parade, and I suspect the same would be true for most residents. The society should have used the yearly event to educate the community about the character they were “supposedly” celebrating. If community members were to understand that these literary works were of a time period, right or wrong and used their own judgement on whether they were interested in participating.
By choosing such a derogatory image for the festival pamphlet, they have chosen to make the character Sam Slick about “something”, and that something is insulting to all residents of this community. Whether the printing of this image was intentional, or made in error as an oversight, there is no excuse this image being promoted. The society has taken a “weak’ approach on addressing the public with an explanation, or at least a proper apology and that is very disappointing to everyone involved.

Black And Beautiful

Comment online since July 30th 2008
My comment to "no side" here is that you have to face reality black will never be equal with white but what i was saying is vince upshaw is sitting there defending a men who contridicted himself.
Let me Clear this up for you "no side here" for the sam slick society to print a front cover like they did it discoourages black ppl and also hurts one self-esteem so what i am saying is vince upshaw is a black man and it is like he is trying to protect bruce shaw.
Racism will never stop. so face that fact

no side here

Comment online since July 30th 2008
I am confused after reading Black and Beautiful's comment regarding the "side" in which Vince Upshaw is taking. My understanding of the article is that there should be no "sides" and that all should be equal? Am I misunderstanding the offence that has occured? Perhaps if EVERYONE were on the same page and our young people were not expected to choose "sides" there truly could be less racism in our communities. Please do not forget that racism is not exclusive to the "black ppl". It needs to STOP regarding all walks of life.

black and beautiful

Comment online since July 29th 2008
i am a young black woman who is from the town of windsor. this article made me very upset because i found it very humourous how bruce the head of the sam slick society contridicted himself not only in this paper but also in the chronicle hearld.
But what i find even more humours is that Vince Upshaw a member of the black community says he believes bruce "come on vince upshaw who's side are you on"
As far as the sam slick days go they have just lost all of my business this will be one black woman who will stand proud with her community and protest aganist the racist sam slick. Just when you think that windsor could be getting better and there is less racism something even bigger comes and slaps the black ppl in the face but to all the black ppl keep ya head up.

Reader Poll

  • Are you filling your tank more now that gas prices have dropped?
  • Yes
  • No